Car insurance after a ticket or an at-fault accident in Ontario

A ticket or an at-fault accident will usually raise your price at renewal. How much depends on the ticket and your history, and there are still ways to keep the price in check.

Last reviewed October 14, 2026

How long they count

Most insurers look back about three years for traffic convictions and about six years for at-fault accidents. A minor ticket usually matters much less than speeding well over the limit, distracted driving or a licence suspension.

Who decides fault

In Ontario, fault is set by the Fault Determination Rules, a regulation that assigns responsibility based on the type of collision. If you think a claim was rated incorrectly, ask your agent to review it with the insurer.

Getting the best rate you can

  • Avoid lapses. A gap on top of a ticket makes things worse.
  • Consider paying small damage yourself instead of claiming. Ask your agent before deciding.
  • Ask about accident forgiveness once your record is clean again.
  • Raise deductibles and review optional coverage to offset the increase.

If you have been refused or cancelled

Drivers with several tickets, a suspension or a cancellation for non-payment can still get insured, sometimes through insurers that specialize in higher-risk drivers. Expect a higher price for a few years, then ask for a new quote as items drop off your record.

Common questions

Does a ticket I fought and won count?

No. Only convictions count. If a charge was withdrawn or you were found not guilty, it should not affect your rate.

Should I report a small accident?

In Ontario you must report collisions to police in certain situations, such as injuries or damage above the reporting threshold. Whether to claim on your insurance is a separate decision. Talk to your agent first.

This guide is general information, not advice for your situation. Coverage depends on your insurer and your policy wording. Ask a licensed agent before making changes.

Ready to see what you could save?

Send the basics in about a minute. A licensed insurance agent calls you back the same business day.

Get a quote